REVIEWS & RATINGS
74 reviews 1 2 3 4 5
Minnetonka
Minneapolis
Runs small
If you want the slightly relaxed look on the model, order a size or even two up. I normally wear a 27-28 or 4-6 and the size 8 fit me in this. Also, they do not really look all that special for the price. The side seam detail is cute, but not really that noticeable. At least I got them during the sale.
Sizing: Smaller than Expected
report inappropriate content
Great purchase
I was looking for an alternative to black combat boots, and I'm so glad I found these! Rustic and menswear-ish, these boots are also more refined and less clunky than they appear in the photo. The suede and leather combo is beautiful and the wood sole makes them especially unique.
Sizing: True to Size / As Expected
report inappropriate content
SimplyLife
Sydney ,Australia
easy to drop
maybe I am thin, but it is really easy to drop.
Sizing: Larger than Expected
report inappropriate content
Beauannie
Little Rock, AR
Great boot
I really love this boot! I like the sturdy heel, the lower height of the boot and that it's cut straight across and not higher in front which can make legs appear shorter. They are very comfortable. I went up half a size for a perfect fit.
Sizing: Smaller than Expected
report inappropriate content
megotsaproblem
chicago suburbs
Matte vs. Shine
There are two versions of this boot on here with different leathers. This is a matte flat finish and the calfskin has a bit of a shine to it. I thought I preferred the matte....but I've ultimately decided to go with the calfskin. Great boots. Comfortable.
Sizing: True to Size / As Expected
report inappropriate content
Megallicious
Calgary, Alberta, Canada
What's not to love?
Super comfy and versatile. It will be my favorite bootie for fall. A little pricey but worth it. I have a high arch and I was still able to put them on and remain true to my shoe size.
Sizing: True to Size / As Expected
report inappropriate content
wwei
Auckland, NZ
Amazing boots!!
I've been eyeing these boots for a while and I'm so glad I finally got them! They are so well made, great quality and look amazing and effortlessly cool on. They definitely run true to size and are super comfortable and easy to walk in. I love them!!
Sizing: True to Size / As Expected
report inappropriate content
Esss
New York, New York
definitlely for narrow feet
Oh how I want these to fit. They came in the mail yesterday and I have been wearing them non-stop in the house to see if I think I can get away with the pain. I've done a lot of research since I got these to see if they tend to stretch, and it seems like they will eventuallyyyyy mold to your feet (one person said give it about three solid wears and it will get better). I don't think I really have wide feet, but I always wear heels to work which has definitely changed the shape of my foot over time. I'm still not sure if I'm keeping them. Ladies, if you don't have a narrow foot then beware. The length seems to be true to size. I've read that if you size up then the heel tends to slip. They are beautiful, the heel is the perfect height for walking around, and they seem to be really well made.
Sizing: Smaller than Expected
report inappropriate content
Tracee3d2
Greenbrae, CA
Absolutely perfect for everyday wear.
They look great and feel so comfortable; hidden elastics are brilliant. I walked 4 miles in them today and my feet don't hurt at all. Heel height and shaft length are perfect for everyday. I wear 37.5 Rag & Bone Newbury and 38 Isabel Marant Dicker booties. and 37.5 fit perfectly.
Sizing: True to Size / As Expected
report inappropriate content
Liz Y.
Berkeley, CA
perfect
love love love these boots. i was a little apprehensive since the fit was a little tight to begin with, but the leather is plush and has stretched to fit my foot perfectly. ankle shaft hits perfectly at a flattering point on the leg. can be worn with pants of all lengths, cuffed or no cuff, skirt, dress, leggings, everything, these boots hit the mark. i had been eyeing these boots forever, and i'm so happy i finally pulled the trigger.
Sizing: True to Size / As Expected
report inappropriate content
Not impressed.
There was a storewide discount offer, so of course I was going to get these boots. I have been eyeing these boots for awhile, it's hard to find well made minimal black boots these days. However, I was pretty disappointed in them once received. The leather had markings as if it had been clipped for awhile, the construction was not carefully done (one side of the boot was higher than the other), and the leather quality just did not seem like $400 quality leather. On the bright side, it is a beautiful concept for the miniimalist look. It was very comfortable (I got a half size larger, but my feet are pretty narrow so it was slightly roomy on me) and it elongated my legs. But I just believe there is a more well made boot out there within the same price range. Sadly I will be returning these. And the black boot hunt continues....
Sizing: True to Size / As Expected
report inappropriate content
Finally found my booties
I am keeping those! Liked it much better than Pistol by Acne. The are more feminine and don't make my size 10 foot look huge (unlike Pistol). Walkable heel, look good with skirts as well. I finally found comfortable boot with high shaft. Also liked it better than Rag and Boone ones, I can manage the heel better since I commute a lot
Sizing: True to Size / As Expected
report inappropriate content
saragl
menlo park, ca
Everything you want in a R Comey boot
stylish, comfortable, great looking. Love my Mars boots but needed a lower heel. This fits the bill.
Sizing: True to Size / As Expected
report inappropriate content
saragl
menlo park, ca
super, super small
I tried these on when they arrived yesterday and I felt like they were made for a Barbie doll. Seriously. I am usually a 26 and I couldn't zip the size 4. Very stiff fabric, too.
Sizing: Smaller than Expected
report inappropriate content
BitsiKitty
Rockville,MD
Rachel Comey Mars Mules
This is an attractive mule. But what size to get is difficult to determine.They fit much smaller than your usual size. I bought the 36 and 36.5, and neither size fit. I usually take a 36 in this type of shoe. I was shocked, and upset because having to guess size is a complete waste of time. Someone needs to do a sample fit test on this designer's shoe and offer advice to potential customers.
Sizing: Smaller than Expected
report inappropriate content