REVIEWS & RATINGS
57 reviews 1 2 3 4
Beauannie
Little Rock, AR
Great boot
I really love this boot! I like the sturdy heel, the lower height of the boot and that it's cut straight across and not higher in front which can make legs appear shorter. They are very comfortable. I went up half a size for a perfect fit.
Sizing: Smaller than Expected
report inappropriate content
megotsaproblem
chicago suburbs
Matte vs. Shine
There are two versions of this boot on here with different leathers. This is a matte flat finish and the calfskin has a bit of a shine to it. I thought I preferred the matte....but I've ultimately decided to go with the calfskin. Great boots. Comfortable.
Sizing: True to Size / As Expected
report inappropriate content
Megallicious
Calgary, Alberta, Canada
What's not to love?
Super comfy and versatile. It will be my favorite bootie for fall. A little pricey but worth it. I have a high arch and I was still able to put them on and remain true to my shoe size.
Sizing: True to Size / As Expected
report inappropriate content
wwei
Auckland, NZ
Amazing boots!!
I've been eyeing these boots for a while and I'm so glad I finally got them! They are so well made, great quality and look amazing and effortlessly cool on. They definitely run true to size and are super comfortable and easy to walk in. I love them!!
Sizing: True to Size / As Expected
report inappropriate content
Esss
New York, New York
definitlely for narrow feet
Oh how I want these to fit. They came in the mail yesterday and I have been wearing them non-stop in the house to see if I think I can get away with the pain. I've done a lot of research since I got these to see if they tend to stretch, and it seems like they will eventuallyyyyy mold to your feet (one person said give it about three solid wears and it will get better). I don't think I really have wide feet, but I always wear heels to work which has definitely changed the shape of my foot over time. I'm still not sure if I'm keeping them. Ladies, if you don't have a narrow foot then beware. The length seems to be true to size. I've read that if you size up then the heel tends to slip. They are beautiful, the heel is the perfect height for walking around, and they seem to be really well made.
Sizing: Smaller than Expected
report inappropriate content
Tracee3d2
California
Absolutely perfect for everyday wear.
They look great and feel so comfortable; hidden elastics are brilliant. I walked 4 miles in them today and my feet don't hurt at all. Heel height and shaft length are perfect for everyday. I wear 37.5 Rag & Bone Newbury and 38 Isabel Marant Dicker booties. and 37.5 fit perfectly.
Sizing: True to Size / As Expected
report inappropriate content
Liz Y.
Berkeley, CA
perfect
love love love these boots. i was a little apprehensive since the fit was a little tight to begin with, but the leather is plush and has stretched to fit my foot perfectly. ankle shaft hits perfectly at a flattering point on the leg. can be worn with pants of all lengths, cuffed or no cuff, skirt, dress, leggings, everything, these boots hit the mark. i had been eyeing these boots forever, and i'm so happy i finally pulled the trigger.
Sizing: True to Size / As Expected
report inappropriate content
dyla
san francisco
Wonky first pair-- second was better
I love the idea of these. I have a couple pair of Mars booties and had high hopes for these. The first pair I got were totally strange. The leather on the inside of the mule seemed to be coming apart. It was shaped weird and felt kind of awful. I ordered a half size down and the bootie was much more to my liking. I love the look but the quality is a bit unpredictable.
Sizing: True to Size / As Expected
report inappropriate content
Jen D
Chicago, IL USA
Underwhelming & Not Worth the $$
I was so excited about these because it's impossible to find cute rain boots and I thought the leopard lining in these would look so chic and stylish peeking out from the inside. One small problem: when the boots are on your feet you can't see the leopard AT ALL. Which makes them just little short black lace up rubber boots with nothing really that special about them and definitely not worth nearly 300 dollars! Sadly, I had to return them :(
Sizing: True to Size / As Expected
report inappropriate content
Jill Stein
Manhattan, NY
Beautiful booties!
I love these booties - they're a great color and very comfy. The height of the shaft is perfect too. They did feel tight in the toes, but I tried the next half size and they were too big. It seems that these run narrow but true to size. I'm having them stretched a tad and they should be perfect!
Sizing: True to Size / As Expected
report inappropriate content
marysaleah
Brooklyn, NY
Ankle boot perfection
I was searching for the perfect ankle boot based on a photo I saw on Pinterest. Unbeknownst to me, the boot in the picture was actually the Rachel Comey Mars. I couldn't believe I actually found the exact shoe I was looking for. They are everything I wanted. I love the hidden elastic on the inner ankle that takes place of a zipper. It's hard to find booties without zippers or visible elastic, and these are so minimal and classic. I have fickle feet with lots of corns that are usually irritated by narrow toe shoes. I have some rag & bone booties that squeeze my toes terribly, but amazingly that's not a problem in these. The first day I wore them I walked about 40 blocks with no blisters or rubbing at all. Like I said, perfect!
Sizing: True to Size / As Expected
report inappropriate content
HeatherL
San Diego, CA
huge, tent-like
This dress was huge - especially the skirt part. From the pix it had so much potential, the top was nice, the material great, good color. I ordered a M/10. sadly it was sent back :(
Sizing: Larger than Expected
report inappropriate content
wwei
Auckland, NZ
Beautiful but narrow
I love Rachel Comey shoes, they're such great quality. I love this pair of lace ups, they're beautiful but very narrow, however I've given them 5 stars anyway because I like them so much and it's worth the pain of breaking them in. They look so smart, go with anything and make your feet look smaller.
Sizing: True to Size / As Expected
report inappropriate content
Beautiful shoes but sizing problem
I love these shoes. They are beautifully crafted and the distressed silver hue is perfect! Unfortunately, this is at least half a size too small. And worse, it is very narrow. I don't have wide feet and it already feels too snug on the sides. The padding on the insole is comfy, but only serves to make the shoe feel even smaller. I'm in 2 minds...should I return them or risk attempting to break them in? If you're purchasing this, I strongly suggest you get them half a size larger. And if you have wide feet, don't even bother!
Sizing: Smaller than Expected
report inappropriate content
moon576
New York, NY
Very comfortable
I have these and I adore them. They are super comfortable even though they are quite high. They make your legs go on for miles and I love the chunky heel. Got the 6.5 and I'm always a Rachel Comey 6.5.
Sizing: True to Size / As Expected
report inappropriate content